True Story

One Stunt Gone Wrong: What You Never Knew About Esther Williams, Hollywood’s Most Dazzling and Damaged Mermaid

Products are selected by our editors, we may earn commission from links on this page.

Esther Williams dazzled audiences with aquatic grace, but behind the sequins and synchronized smiles was a life shaped by scandal, injury, and studio manipulation. In one stunt gone wrong, studios being studios did the unthinkable and turned her world upside down.

A Complicated Beginning She Never Asked For

Credit to frombeneaththehollywoodsign.com

Esther grew up with a quiet sense that something wasn’t quite right in her relationship with her mother, though she couldn’t explain exactly why at first.

Years later, the truth surfaced: Esther was an unplanned fifth child, and her mother had gone to extreme lengths to avoid her birth. It was a heartbreaking revelation.

Still, on August 8, 1921, Esther entered the world—uninvited, perhaps, but determined. Her life began under a cloud, yet she carried herself with grace far beyond those first shadows.

The Spotlight Dimmed Too Soon

Credit to Wikimedia Commons

Esther wasn’t the only star-in-the-making in her family. Her brother Stanton had his own moment in the limelight, catching the eye of actress Marjorie Rambeau.

That connection led him to the big screen, where he landed roles in two films in 1920. Just as his career began to bloom, everything took a devastating turn.

At only 16, Stanton died suddenly from a burst colon. His untimely death left a deep scar on the family, casting a long shadow over the years that followed.

The Secret Esther Carried for Two Years

Credit to u/Glass-Tale299 via Reddit

After losing her son, Esther’s mother, Bula, invited 16-year-old Buddy McClure into their home, hoping he might ease the family’s grief. But his presence brought hidden danger.

Behind what seemed like an act of kindness, Esther was forced into silence after Buddy assaulted her. Afraid and unsure, she carried this painful secret alone.

It took two years before she could speak up. Buddy was finally sent away, but the emotional scars he left behind stayed with Esther for the rest of her life.

Finding Peace in the Pool

Credit to u/systemsofromance via Reddit

With her life in turmoil, Esther searched for something that could bring her peace. She found it in swimming, a quiet refuge from everything happening around her.

Since she didn’t have a pool at home, Esther took a job at the local one, folding towels just to stay close to the water she loved.

There, she trained relentlessly, even mastering strokes that most girls avoided. Swimming became more than a hobby—it was her escape, strength, and new beginning.

When Talent Met Opportunity

Billy Rose (Credit to Wikimedia Commons)

At just 16, Esther had already made serious waves—literally. She snagged three national titles in breaststroke and freestyle, proving she was more than just potential.

Her rising star caught the attention of Billy Rose, mastermind of the Aquacade, a dazzling mix of water, music, and synchronized spectacle. He saw something special in Esther.

He promised her a spot the moment one opened. Esther, thrilled beyond words, said yes—completely unaware that this was just the beginning of an extraordinary and unexpected journey.

She Dated a Producer—Then Ghosted His Movie

Credit to @books0977 via Tumblr

Before she was a household name, Esther caught the eye of a powerful producer who came with promises—and romantic interest. At first, she entertained both.

But when the chemistry fizzled, so did her commitment to his pet project. She quietly backed out, leaving him without a star and with a bruised ego.

Word got around. Hollywood may have raised its eyebrows, but Esther walked away unscathed, demonstrating early on that she wasn’t here to please everyone.

A Love That Lost Its Spark

America’s Mermaid, actress-swimmer, Esther Williams, in court for divorce from Dr. Leonard Kovner (Credit to Wikimedia Commons)

While studying physical education at Los Angeles City College, Esther unexpectedly fell for Leonard Kovner, a bright and promising medical student with a steady presence.

They married in 1940, swept up in the idea of a perfect future. But Esther soon realized something was missing beneath the polished surface of their relationship.

Leonard was everything on paper—smart, kind, reliable—but not the match her heart craved. By 1944, the romance had faded, leaving behind a marriage that quietly unraveled.

When the Olympics Didn’t Call, There’s Hollywood

Headed for the 1940 American Olympic Games team is Esther Williams, a 17-year-old Los Angeles Athletic Club swimming sensation. (Credit to Wikimedia Commons)

Esther dreamed big, far beyond the limits of a lackluster marriage. She set her sights on Olympic gold and trained hard for the upcoming games in Japan.

But history had other plans. World War II broke out, and the Olympics were canceled, shattering the dreams of countless athletes, including Esther’s.

With her path to Olympic glory cut short, she found herself heading in a new direction—toward the bright lights of Hollywood, where a different kind of spotlight awaited.

Hollywood’s Splashy Tug-of-War

Sonja Henie (Left) / Esther Williams (Right), Wikimedia Commons

In classic Tinseltown fashion, Fox and MGM were locked in a glittery battle of one-upmanship. Fox had Sonja Henie on ice—literally—boosting their box office appeal.

Not to be outdone, MGM turned to Esther Williams, the swimming sensation. She agreed to join—but only with time to train in acting and access to a proper pool.

That pool? The one at the Beverly Hills Hotel. Her conditions were met, but her rise also revealed the reality beneath the glam: Hollywood was dazzling, but rarely simple.

She Refused to Sleep Her Way to the Top—and Paid for It

Credit to @dweemeister via Tumblr

Unlike many of her contemporaries, Esther made it clear early on: her roles were earned, not negotiated behind closed doors. Not everyone appreciated that boundary.

Some producers took her refusal personally. Promising scripts suddenly vanished from her schedule. Her career stayed afloat, but not without tension just under the surface.

Still, she refused to compromise. Her path may have been tougher, but it was paved with dignity—and just enough defiance to make her unforgettable.

When Hollywood Played Its Dirty Games

Clark Gable & Lana Turner in “Somewhere I’ll Find You” (1942) (Credit to @tcm via Tumblr)

Eager and wide-eyed, Esther stepped into Hollywood and landed a dream role—Lana Turner’s lead in Somewhere I’ll Find You—after Turner took off on a surprise elopement.

But the glitz didn’t last. MGM had a plan up its sleeve, using Esther as bait to spark jealousy and reel Turner back into the spotlight.

Once Turner returned, Esther was swiftly pushed aside. It stung, but her determination held strong—and soon enough, Hollywood handed her another shot at the screen.

From Hollywood Performances to Hospitals?

Credit to u/Glass-Tale299 via Reddit

During the height of World War II, Esther stepped into the spotlight—not in theaters, but in hospitals, performing for wounded servicemen in need of joy and escape.

Her act blended humor, grace, and just enough flirtation to lift spirits. With clever lines and playful rejections, she offered comfort through laughter.

The grand finale? She’d reveal a dazzling gold lamé swimsuit, leaving the room grinning and stunned. It was bold and unforgettable, and it was the moment many first saw Esther Williams shine.

The Studio That Wanted to ‘Upgrade’ Her Face

Credit to Screenbound Entertainment via Pinterest

Just before landing her big break, MGM pulled her aside with a “small” suggestion: a little cosmetic work to make her “camera-ready.” Esther declined without hesitation.

Executives weren’t thrilled. They expected compliance. But Esther stuck to her guns—and her nose—refusing to let Hollywood’s obsession with perfection shape her future.

And she was right. The public adored her as-is, proving that you didn’t need plastic to become a star. Just talent. And a killer breaststroke.

Servicemen Were Just So Obsessed With Her

Credit to rickterenzi via Pinterest

Esther Williams didn’t just entertain—she enchanted. Her performances left servicemen smitten, turning her into one of the most sought-after icons of World War II.

In 1943, a single signed photo of her caused an all-out frenzy among troops, proving just how powerful her presence had become, even from a distance.

Contests for her autograph spread across military bases. Some got creative, others competitive, so much so that injuries weren’t uncommon. All for a glimpse of Hollywood’s golden girl.

The Role That Made Her a Star

Credit to elce59 via Pinterest

A year after the autograph frenzy sent four servicemen to the hospital, Esther landed a major role alongside comedian Red Skelton in a lighthearted college comedy.

Originally meant to highlight Skelton’s antics as he tried to win back his swimmer fiancée, the film took a turn once Esther hit the screen.

Her performance stole the show, so much so that producers renamed the film Bathing Beauty, ditching Mr. Coed and officially launching Esther into Hollywood stardom.

Banking on Esther

Shooting the Overhead shots from Esther Williams’ “Bathing Beauty”, 1944 (Credit to r/Moviesinthemaking via Reddit)

Bathing Beauty wasn’t just a hit—it was a signal. MGM saw the magic in Esther’s water-filled performances and knew they had something no one else did.

To keep their aquatic queen shining, they went big—really big. The studio built a custom pool for a whopping $250,000, a bold move in classic Hollywood.

This wasn’t just a pretty set piece. It had high-tech features to capture every elegant stroke and dive, proving MGM was all-in on their newest star.

Riding the Wave of Success

Esther Williams, Bathing Beauty, 1944 (Credit to u/lllopqolll via Reddit)

MGM struck gold with Esther’s debut film, which splashed at the box office and triggered a rush to recreate the magic as quickly as possible.

They had everything they needed: a breakout star, a shiny new pool, and a flexible script that could be dressed up and repackaged with ease.

Esther herself noticed the déjà vu in the sequels, but audiences didn’t seem to mind. Her waterlogged charm kept ticket sales soaring—and MGM happily cashed in.

Standing Up to the Boss

Credit to r/todayilearned via Reddit

Esther was one of MGM’s biggest assets, helping the studio thrive under the reign of its powerful and often intimidating co-founder, Louis B. Mayer.

Most stars stayed quiet during Mayer’s infamous outbursts—but not Esther. She had no problem standing her ground when it mattered most.

Confident in her value, she famously told Mayer to criticize her only if he could outswim her. He couldn’t, of course—and the message was crystal clear.

What She Told Deborah Kerr

Credit to anarosarp and bdeyes1939 via Pinterest

Esther entered Hollywood without expecting trophies or top billing—but as her success climbed, so did her belief in her own star power.

With each hit, her confidence grew louder. She didn’t let her inexperience hold her back, even when standing beside Hollywood’s more traditional leading ladies.

At one point, she even told Deborah Kerr that one of her splashy swimming flicks could fund two of Kerr’s serious dramas. A bold claim—part pride, part proof of her rising clout.

Joy Came With A Cost

Credit to Wikimedia Commons

With her career soaring, Esther longed for more than just success—she wanted a partner who brought passion, not predictability like her first husband.

Enter Ben Gage: charming, fun, and everything her previous marriage wasn’t. Their life together was full of laughter, love, and eventually, three children.

But joy came with a cost. Gage’s struggles with alcoholism and reckless spending drained $10 million of Esther’s hard-earned fortune, turning their dream life into a difficult new chapter.

She Knew He Was a Financial Disaster—and Married Him Anyway

Credit to Wikimedia Commons

Ben Gage’s money mismanagement was no secret. Friends warned her, and accountants winced. But Esther fell hard and ignored all the warning signs.

They tied the knot despite his history of burning through paychecks faster than he could earn them. Red flags? She swam right past them.

Years later, she admitted she’d seen it coming but chose to believe love could fix it. Spoiler: It couldn’t.

Trouble Followed Her to Mexico

Credit to Wikimedia Commons

In 1947, while filming Fiesta in Mexico, Esther was riding high in her career—until an uninvited visit from her husband, Ben Gage, stirred a sense of dread.

Gage’s arrival didn’t bring support or celebration. Instead, it unleashed chaos, beginning with arguments and quickly spiraling into a full-blown scene at the hotel.

Things escalated so badly that police were involved, and Gage was ordered out of the country. What should’ve been a triumph turned into another chapter of turmoil.

Behind the Scenes Was No Fiesta

Credit to Metek09 via Pinterest

Filming Fiesta in Mexico was anything but a party for Esther. She witnessed several stuntmen injured by bulls and narrowly avoided the dangers of unfamiliar local food.

While the crew embraced the street food scene, their enthusiasm turned tragic—some contracted cholera, and a few didn’t survive. The mood was anything but festive.

Despite the heartbreak, Esther faced even more threats during her time on set than off. It was a production full of risk, far beyond the script.

She Punched a Stuntman—Allegedly

Credit to reneetownsend01 via Pinterest

One too many close calls led to high tensions. When a stuntman got a little too handsy during a scene, Esther reportedly gave him a quick and decisive right hook.

The crew didn’t talk, but the whispers were loud. They said Esther didn’t tolerate disrespect, especially not while floating in a sequined corset.

Whether the story’s true or not, one thing’s clear: she wasn’t just tough in the pool.

The Outfit That Nearly Sank Her

A Scene from This Time for Keeps (1947)

In This Time for Keeps, costume design took a wrong turn—Esther found herself in a heavy plaid flannel suit that had no business near a swimming pool.

Once in the water, the fabric soaked up like a sponge and dragged her under. It quickly turned from a fashion faux pas into a serious safety hazard.

Thinking fast, she ditched the soggy mess and resurfaced, laughing. That near-miss pushed Esther to champion smarter, safer swimwear for all her future roles.

Esther as Hollywood’s Swimwear Spokesperson

Credit to @tcm via Tumblr

After nearly drowning in a plaid disaster, Esther had enough of Hollywood’s cluelessness about swimwear and decided to make a difference outside the screen.

She partnered with Cole Swimwear and became more than a face—she became a voice, especially for women in the U.S. Navy stuck with unflattering, impractical suits.

Esther’s redesigned swimsuit was a hit, earning a 50,000-unit order from the Navy. It didn’t fix her film set frustrations, but it proved she could make waves where it mattered.

The Price of Looking Like a Mermaid Is Danger

Credit to charliejanestar via Pinterest

In The Million Dollar Mermaid (1952), Esther wasn’t battling lines or choreography—her real challenge was the costume that glittered but didn’t forgive.

Covered in 50,000 gold sequins, the outfit was breathtaking on camera but brutal in water, weighing her down and making movement painfully difficult.

As if that weren’t enough, she wore a stiff aluminum crown that added to the discomfort—all before being asked to perform one of the film’s most daring scenes.

The Dive That Went Too Far

Video from Million Dollar Mermaid (Credit to @venusoftheseas via Tumblr)

For one dramatic scene, Esther was lifted 60 feet into the air, ready to dive in full costume—including that infamous aluminum crown—despite her growing unease.

At director Mervyn LeRoy’s cue, she took the plunge, performing the dive flawlessly and earning his immediate approval. But something wasn’t right beneath the surface.

Moments later, a cry for help echoed from the pool—Esther was hurt. What began as a cinematic stunt quickly became a real emergency needing urgent medical attention.

And The Dive That Broke Her (Literally)

Video from Million Dollar Mermaid (Credit to @venusoftheseas via Tumblr)

Esther knew diving with a metal crown was risky, but the demands of Hollywood often pushed caution aside. She jumped—and instantly knew something had gone wrong.

A sharp snap in her neck struck panic. What seemed like a stunning stunt was actually a serious injury that no one initially grasped the full extent of.

The crown had fractured three vertebrae, landing her in a body cast for six months, right in the middle of the set she once loved most.

She Faked Being Okay to Keep the Paycheck

Credit to @dweemeister via Tumblr

Recovery? Optional, apparently. Despite being in a body cast, Esther pushed herself back to work too soon, unwilling to risk her standing with MGM.

She smiled through interviews and wrapped herself in glamour, all while her spine was healing inch by painful inch.

It was the ultimate Hollywood illusion—Esther looked picture-perfect, even while quietly breaking down behind the scenes.

Love, Injury, and On-Set Secrets

Credit to cw05012 via Pinterest

Million Dollar Mermaid was Esther’s favorite film, so much so that she named her autobiography after it. Ironically, it also gave her the worst injury of her career.

Behind the glamour, she shared more than scenes with co-star Victor Mature. Their off-screen romance was as heated as the spotlight they stood under.

But everything changed after her diving accident. As Esther recovered in a body cast, the romance fizzled, leaving behind a film full of success, scandal, and personal pain.

When the Studio Turned Its Back

Jupiter’s Darling (Credit to @classicmoviehub via Instagram)

Esther had brought MGM more than $80 million in box office gold, but one flop was all the studio needed to cool its affection.

That flop was Jupiter’s Darling in 1955, where she played Amytis in a musical-meets-history mashup that didn’t exactly charm audiences or critics.

Despite her track record, MGM dismissed her past success. Feeling betrayed, Esther didn’t sulk—she started quietly planning a bit of payback, Hollywood-style.

She Was Offered a Comeback—With a Catch

Credit to @T__twitt via X

After her final MGM film flopped, one rival studio dangled a lifeline: a lead role in a high-budget musical, but with an “image update” that made her flinch.

They wanted her to dye her hair, lose weight, and wear racier costumes to compete with rising bombshells. Esther, in her 30s, was suddenly “too wholesome.”

She declined the role and the makeover. It was a bold move, but it came at a price—her phone stopped ringing. Hollywood’s message was clear: evolve or evaporate. Esther refused both.

Fired, Furious, and Revenge

Credit to gloriapolicano via Pinterest

One failed film was all it took—MGM dropped Esther without hesitation, shaking both her career and her already rocky marriage.

But Esther wasn’t one to fade quietly. Fueled by frustration, she set her sights on Jeff Chandler, Universal’s leading man and one of MGM’s top competitors.

Their romance was gaining traction until a startling revelation about Chandler stopped everything in its tracks, turning Esther’s comeback into yet another emotional detour.

The Secret That Made Her Dump Jeff Chandler

Credit to gloriapolicano via Pinterest

Things unraveled quickly when Esther discovered Chandler’s personal secret—he occasionally wore women’s clothing in private, which deeply unsettled her.

It wasn’t just the discovery that drove a wedge between them. It was the betrayal of trust and the pressure to keep it hidden.

She ended the relationship immediately and remained silent for years. When she finally revealed it in her autobiography, it stirred a storm of debate and mixed reactions.

Healing But Hollywood Style (Yikes!)

Credit to rickterenzi and la_delicatesse via Pinterest

Reeling from heartbreak after her split with Jeff Chandler, Esther was open to anything that might help her make sense of the emotional chaos.

She turned to none other than Cary Grant, who had found his own unconventional path to healing. His suggestion? LSD—yes, the psychedelic kind.

Curious and willing, Esther tried it. The result, she later said, felt like “instant psychoanalysis,” marking one of the most unusual chapters in her journey to self-discovery.

The Marriage She Had to Leave

Credit to cakeicer via Pinterest

Years of financial chaos and mounting debt, including a $750,000 debt to the IRS, finally pushed Esther to her breaking point in 1959.

Her husband, Ben Gage, had mishandled more than just money. After years of emotional and financial strain, Esther knew it was time to walk away.

In court, she summed it up perfectly: “I’m tired of being what my husband does for a living.” The judge agreed, and her troubled marriage came to an overdue end.

Falling for Fernando

Credit to reneetownsend01 via Pinterest

After closing the chapter with Ben Gage, Esther found herself drawn to Fernando Lamas—the dashing Argentine actor she’d admired from afar.

Their chemistry led to marriage in 1961, but life with Fernando came with strings. He was traditional to a fault, expecting full devotion and domestic submission.

He even destroyed photos of her exes, uncomfortable with her past. Esther obliged—for a while, embracing a love that was anything but simple.

The Ultimatum That Changed Everything

Credit to reneetownsend01 via Pinterest

Esther’s 1969 marriage to Fernando Lamas was unconventional, but it also came with painful conditions that tested her limits as a mother and partner.

Lamas, troubled by her past and her children from a previous marriage, issued an ultimatum: him or them. It was a decision no parent should face.

Shockingly, Esther chose him—at least publicly. She continued to care for her children in secret, all while describing their emotionally fraught relationship as an impossible ideal that lasted until his death in 1982.

She Chose a Man Over Her Kids—Then Regretted It

Credit to reneetownsend01 via Pinterest

Esther’s most controversial choice haunted her: choosing a man over her children. It wasn’t complete abandonment, but the damage was deep and lasting.

She kept contact with her children in private, trying to balance appearances and affection in unequal measure.

Later in life, she admitted the guilt never left her. For all the applause she earned onscreen, some of her loudest regrets came from behind closed doors.

Rebuilding After Goodbye

Credit to chictiquescafe and sdavismartin via Pinterest

Esther’s years with Fernando Lamas came at a steep price—her career, her independence, and precious time with her children slipped away during their marriage.

But his passing marked a powerful shift. Esther began healing old wounds, starting with rebuilding bonds with her children, whom she had long kept at a distance.

From there, she launched a successful swimwear line and finally lived out her Olympic dream—proof that even after deep loss, a new beginning is always possible.

Her Olympic Dream Came True—In Her Own Way

Esther Williams / rehearsing her underwater ballet for the film Ziegfeld Follies / Los Angeles, June 1944. (Credit to r/1940s via Reddit)

Though she never competed as an athlete, Esther’s Olympic moment finally arrived in 1984 when her hometown of Los Angeles hosted the Games.

At 63, she couldn’t swim for medals but didn’t need to. Her joy peaked when synchronized swimming—her beloved sport—was added to the Olympic lineup.

Honored as the “godmother of synchronized swimming,” Esther was finally recognized for the legacy she’d built in and out of the water. Her dream, though delayed, had arrived.

Her Last and Lasting Love

Credit to @elpasadodepuertomontt via Instagram

In 1994, Esther Williams married Edward Bell—her fourth and final husband—at a time when the Hollywood lights had long dimmed and peace meant more than fame.

Bell, an actor and artist, offered the kind of steady companionship Esther had longed for after decades of personal turbulence and public life.

Their bond was built on mutual respect and quiet support. He stood by her through business ventures, interviews, and reflections, remaining her partner until her passing in 2013.

The Family Feud After Her Death

Credit to EWSwimwear via Pinterest

Even in death, Esther stirred the waters. Disputes emerged among family members over her estate, memoir rights, and the use of her image.

One camp wanted to honor her legacy quietly; another eyed business ventures. The battle was subdued, but it exposed the fragile peace behind the perfect press releases.

In the end, Esther’s legacy prevailed. But the headlines proved what she always knew—family drama doesn’t end when the credits roll.

A Farewell to the Water