Shelves for Amana Refrigerators: Ultimate Product Comparison Guide

Amana refrigerators are not just well-loved, but high-quality. They’re the sort of fridge that you’ll have in your life for decades. You love Amana refrigerators, but do you have it optimized to fit all your needs? Is your fridge exactly how you want it? A great way to add some much-needed organization to your space is with a set of door shelves. We’re comparing two different, popular door shelves that work with Amana refrigerators. We’re focusing on price, brand reputation, compatibility, quality, dimensions, and material. All of the comparison is focused on letting you make an informed decision.

Price Comparison

The prices for both of these products for Amana refrigerators are pretty on par. If you’re worried about a budget, both of these fridge shelf options are pretty reasonable. The Door Shelf Bin is $28.90 and the Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin is $22.94. The price difference isn’t so big that choosing one over the other would be an issue.

The cost factor is obviously really important. With a price difference of $5.96 between the two items, you can make a simple decision about which shelves you want. You don’t have to worry about breaking the bank, but if you’re really trying to pinch pennies, you’ll want to go with the more affordable pack.

Shelf Bin Compatibility with Amana Refrigerators

You want to consider the compatibility of these shelves with all sorts of refrigerator brands. The Door Shelf Bin is designed to work with a wide range of refrigerators, including Frigidaire, Whirlpool, Kenmore, Roper, Amana, Crosley, and Estate models. This compatibility offers flexibility for consumers with different refrigerator brands, ensuring they can easily replace or upgrade their existing door shelf bins without compatibility issues.

The Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin is another option that provides compatibility with similar refrigerator brands. These shelves work with Frigidaire, Whirlpool, Kenmore, Roper, Amana, Crosley, and Estate. With this product, you can conveniently and easily replace or add door shelf bins to your fridge without worrying about brand-specific limitations. The ability to use these shelf bins across multiple refrigerator brands adds to the versatility and convenience.

Of the Door Shelf Bins, one reviewer writes, “Fit my Amana fridge perfectly. Will order again if needed in other shelves.”

Of the Refrigerator Door Shelf Bins, one customers writes, “it fits like if was made by amana refrigerator. they are very sturdy, easy to remove for easy cleaning.”

Quality Comparison

Quality is a crucial factor to consider when comparing products, especially when it comes to refrigerator accessories. You want to be sure that your shelves are sturdy enough to keep everything in place. The material and durability of these shelf bins can greatly impact performance and longevity.

The Door Shelf Bin is designed with environmentally friendly materials. They ensure there’s no pollution and promote safety and health. They’re made from high-quality, durable materials that exceed OEM specifications. This shelf bin is easy to install, which saves you time and money on professional installation services. With a 365-day warranty, this product offers quality assurance and customer satisfaction.

On the other hand, the Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin emphasizes premium quality. Made from high-quality material, this shelf bin is built to last, providing long-lasting performance. If you need a replacement shelf that is easy to install and offers additional storage space, this product is a viable option.

About the Door Shelf Bin, one reviewer writes, “Bins fit great in our 10 year old Kenmore side by side. We replaced two broken or cracked door bins that were clear plastic, which seems more fragile than these white plastic bins. We expect a long life, most likely longer than the fridge itself is going to last!”

A Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin reviewer writes, “I have a Kenmore side by side refrigerator, and it works very well, but I have had to replace some of the clear plastic shelves and drawers that broke from use. If I had bought the clear acrylic ones, they are roughly four times the price as the plain white ones. They fit my fridge perfectly. Make sure to get your make and model before ordering to ensure a correct fit.”

Dimensions to Fit Amana Refrigerators

You, of course, have to consider the dimensions of the shelves you purchase. The size of the shelf bin can play a significant role in how well it fits into your refrigerator and how much storage space it gives you. Understanding the dimensions of the shelf bin can help you determine if it will be a suitable replacement for your current one.

When looking at the dimensions of the shelf bins for the Amana refrigerators, both products offer a size of 16-3/8″ in length, 6-1/4″ in width, and 3-1/4″ in height. This standard size makes them compatible with a range of refrigerator models from all sorts of brands. Because both shelves are made to fit beautifully in almost any fridge, they tie in this category.

Comparing Material Quality

You’ll want to also consider what sort of materials the shelves are made out of. The material used in the construction of these bins can impact their durability and performance.

The Door Shelf Bin is designed with environmentally friendly materials, ensuring safety, health, and high durability. It meets OEM specifications and is easy to install, saving time and money on installation. The Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin is made from high-quality material for long-lasting performance. It is a premium quality replacement part that is simple to operate and easy to replace.

This is another category in which the two tie. Both of these replacement parts are high-quality and made from materials that are going to stand up to anything you throw their way.

Which Shelves Are Right for Amana Refrigerators?

Though it’s definitely a tight race, we think that the Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin are the preferred choice for Amana refrigerators. You want something you can add to your kitchen simply and quickly but make a big difference. These shelves are affordable, have a great brand reputation, are compatible with various refrigerator brands, are made with high-quality material, and have universal dimensions. These are great for fitting into almost any fridge and are super easy to use. If you want shelves that are going to add storage and organization in the doors of your fridge, then you’ll want these!

Questions & Answers:

Question: What is the price difference between the Door Shelf Bin and the 2 Pack 2187172 Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin for Amana refrigerators?

Answer: The price difference between the Door Shelf Bin and the 2 Pack 2187172 Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin for Amana refrigerators is $5.96.

Question: How does the brand influence the decision-making process when comparing Amana refrigerators?

Answer: The brand reflects the reputation, quality, and customer service standards you can expect, influencing trust and reliability in the product.

Question: Are the Amana refrigerator door shelf bins compatible with various refrigerator brands?

Answer: Yes, both the Door Shelf Bin and the 2 Pack 2187172 Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin are compatible with a wide range of refrigerator brands, offering flexibility for consumers.

Question: What is the quality comparison between the Door Shelf Bin by MONKEMON and the 2 Pack 2187172 Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin by Discount Parts Direct?

Answer: Both products emphasize premium quality, with durable materials and easy installation features. The Door Shelf Bin by MONKEMON offers environmentally friendly materials and a 365-day warranty, while the 2 Pack 2187172 Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin focuses on long-lasting performance.

Question: What are the dimensions of the shelf bins for Amana refrigerators?

Answer: Both the Door Shelf Bin and the 2 Pack 2187172 Refrigerator Door Shelf Bin for Amana refrigerators have dimensions of 16-3/8″ in length, 6-1/4″ in width, and 3-1/4″ in height.

Question: How does the material quality of the Amana refrigerator shelf bins impact their performance?

Answer: The material quality of the Amana refrigerator shelf bins impacts their durability and performance. Both products are designed with high-quality materials to ensure long-lasting performance and ease of installation.